Author Archives: Mark Herzer

Amillennialism

Amillennialism[1]

Introduction

That there are at least four major views to the end times (eschatology) question should cause us to pause. As mentioned before, all these views teach Christ’s personal return, the resurrection of every person, the judgment of all men, the eternal blessedness of the redeemed, and the everlasting punishment of the wicked. In these matters, we are all in agreement. An illustration will reveal where the differences might lie. We all know that the USA defeated the Taliban in Afghanistan and ousted Saddam Hussein in Iraq. On those major issues, all are in agreement. However, the account of those events may differ somewhat, depending on one’s political view. In addition, the purpose and reason for those events are under dispute. Similarly, all genuine Christians agree on the above items, but many of us disagree on how it will all come about.

Various Millennial Views

Our study on the rapture and an earlier overview of the question of Israel and the Church have given us an adequate survey of the Dispensational Premillennial position. The other three positions include Classic (or “Historic”) Premillennialism, Postmillennialism, and Amillennialism. The key distinctive element to Classical Premillennialism is its emphasis on a literal millennial reign. They believe Christ will come before the millennium. Many things will happen before Christ’s coming (evangelization of the nations, the great tribulation, apostasy and rebellion, and the appearance of the a personal antichrist).  It is a position maintained (though some details may differ) by some of the early church fathers (Justin Martyr, Ireneaus, Hippolytus, and Lactantius) and some in the Reformation and Puritan centuries.[2] Both The Augsburg Confession (1530, article 17) and the Second Helvetic Confession (11:14) of 1566  denounce a form of premillennialism (they believed that old Jewish beliefs were being resurrected). Most premillennialists were Anabaptists (e.g., Thomas Müntzer) or part of the radical wing of the Reformation movement.[3] Perhaps the most modern exponent would be George E. Ladd and the CRC church historian at Calvin Seminary, Dr. H. Kromminga (also, the Bible Presbyterian Church).

Postmillennialists include Loraine Boettner and most Theonomists. These men believe that Christ will return after the millennium. The thousand years is not an exact number for them but rather represents a lengthy period of time where the gospel will penetrate the world and where God’s word through His Spirit will subdue a large majority of the people on earth. As a result, much peace and good will come of this; nations will work together, and there will be a long span of spiritual prosperity (maybe longer than one thousand years). “This does not mean that there ever will be a time on this earth when every person will be a Christian, or that all sin will be abolished. But it does mean that evil in all its many forms eventually will be reduced to negligible proportions, that Christian principles will be the rule, not the exception, and that Christ will return to a truly Christianized world.”[4]

No one view is entirely satisfactory. Whereas in many other things, we can be dogmatic, in this, we must be tentative. However, that does not mean we cannot draw conclusions. We believe that the amillennial view is the most consistent and scriptural position. Ever since Augustine, many Christians have believed that the millennial reference depicts Christ’s present reign. The reference therefore is symbolic of Christ’s present heavenly reign until His final return. Crassly put, we are in the millennium right now because Christ reigns with power from on high. “The so called ‘signs of the times’ have been present in the world from the time of Christ’s first coming, but they will come to a more intensified, final manifestation just before his Second Coming. The amillennialist therefore expects the bringing of the gospel to all nations and the conversion of the fullness of Israel to be completed before Christ’s return. He also looks for an intensified form of tribulation and apostasy as well as for the appearance of a personal antichrist before the Second Coming.”[5]

Scriptural Defense

Before we can interpret Revelation 20, we need to see some of the other passages that will have a bearing on our overall interpretation.  The Book of Revelation was not written in a vacuum. Christ utilized the apocalyptic imagery of the OT when He revealed Himself to John in the Book of Revelation.

Daniel

Daniel gives us an important insight into the reign of God. Israel had been exiled and her own national sovereignty was taken away. Did God cease to rule since His own people failed? Of course not.

In Daniel 2, we are given Nebuchadnezzar’s dream (vv. 21ff.). The ability to interpret this dream was what set Daniel off from the rest of the wise counselors in Babylon. In it, Daniel speaks of four kingdoms. Every evangelical commentator has interpreted these four kingdoms to be a reference to Babylon, Medo-Persia, Greece and then Rome. Also, every evangelical commentator takes the reference to the rock (vv. 44-45) to be Christ and His rule. Dispensationalists say that it can only be fulfilled if he rules from Jerusalem and is “literal.” So, they place this after the rapture and the great tribulation. But, the rock crushes Rome and all the previous kingdoms. The kingdom therefore is established by Christ’s earthly ministry, namely, by his life, death and resurrection, at His first coming. Dispensationalists read the prophecy like a Jew and expect a national hope—we must read the prophecy as it has been fulfilled in the NT through Christ.  Let us look at the NT evidence that Christ’s kingdom was established. Continue reading

John Bunyan’s Pilgrim’s Progress, A Study Guide, Lesson 2

STUDY SESSION 2

Introduction (pp. 27-41)

Christian meets Goodwill and the Interpreter in this section. In addition, he will cast off his burdens. He has already been misled by Mr. Worldly-wise and will meet someone who will give him better counsel. In a sense, that is what this section is all about, namely, we should receive good instruction in our Christian walk. Bad counsel can lead to the “Slough of Despond” so we should heed godly warnings and instructions.

 

Readers

Goodwill (27)

Christian (27)

Interpreter (29)

Man in an Iron Cage (only 34-5)

Man rising out of Bed (35)

Simple, Sloth, & Presumption (39- very brief)

Formalist (39)

Hypocrisie (39)

 

Vocabulary

Dives (32) = rich man (Latin divitiae)

amity (32) = a friendly relationship (Latin amicus)

Professor (34) = one who professes to be a Christian. Puritans usually used the word negatively.

Garner (36) = granary or grain bin

Fatt (39) = this is apparently a proverb, “every tub”, ergo, “everyone must look after himself” (296)

tro (40) = trow (believe, think)

 

Questions (pp. 27-41)

Page #

27        What do you think the arrows represented? (cf. Eph. 6:16)[1]

28        Good Will’s words “…is the coelestial Glory of so small esteem with him, that he counteth it not worth running the hazards of a few difficulties to obtain it?” are important. Isn’t this way reasoning applicable to all who forsake the faith?

29        Note, he went through the wicket gate. Why was the burden not lifted? Good or bad? (see Observations & Notes on “Burden Loosed” or see question on p. 37 below)

30        Interpreter explains the picture. Who do you think the Interpreter represents? [see Observations & Notes]

30        Explain what Interpreter means when he says, “…is the only Man, whom the Lord of the Place…hath Authorized, to be thy Guide in all difficult places thou mayest meet with in the way…”[2]

30-1     Dust in the Parlor represents original sin. How does the “law” give strength to sin?

31-2     One room leads Christian to “two little Children” named Patience and Passion. What does “Passion” represent and is it an apt name?[3] Why do you think Passion “laughed Patience to scorn”? Why is Patience better off? (see Luke 16:19ff.)

32-3     “Fire burning against a Wall” — what role does the devil play in this picture? Who is the man behind the wall and explain the image? What is the point of the man behind the wall?[4]

33        The story of the “Palace” should be simple to understand. What does it mean?

34        “Man in an Iron Cage” How did he become a “Man of Despair”? Can this happen? Explain his answer to the question, “Is there no hope but you must be kept in this Iron Cage of Despair.”

35-6     A man rose from his bed and was frightened of what he saw. What did he see that made him afraid? Are Christians supposed to live in fear like this?

37        Christian came to the Cross and “his burden loosed from off his Shoulders.”  What is the meaning of this? (see margin) What does it mean when he says that the sight of the Cross “should thus ease him of his burden”? Does this happen once, often, daily, etc. to a believer? (see Observations & Notes on “Burden Loosed”)

39        Simple, Sloth, and Presumption resist Christian’s warnings. Do you know of anyone like one of these? Explain each one.

40        Formality and Hypocrisie were convinced that the way they came in was tolerable. They argued, “[W]hat’s matter which way we get in? if we are in, we are in…” Is there another way of saying this same thing (as said in our generation)? Explain their discussion over the “Coat” (40).

 

Observations & Notes

Goodwill (27)

Goodwill represents the grace of God and/or the Lord Himself. On p. 27 we read: “So when Christian was stepping in, the other gave him a pull…” “The pull given by Goodwill makes it clear: it is God—not man—who opens the gate and pulls the sinner in. Just as Goodwill was the only one who could open the gate, so God alone can bring the sinner into the covenant of grace. It is true that the sinner must knock and must step in, but the faith and repentance that are required of the sinner are the gifts of God.” (Calhoun, 51)

However, Goodwill could simply be the growing conviction of the Lord’s goodness to him. A believer must be persuaded of the Lord’s goodwill towards him or he will despair. This encounter may be the growing conviction of Christian that God is merciful and gracious to the broken hearted. Nonetheless, Goodwill is most likely a reference to Christ (“I am willing with all my heart, said he” 27).

 

Interpreter (30)

Some “interpreters” of Bunyan’s work are divided. Some take him to be the Holy Spirit (Maureen Bradley, 21; Calhoun, 54) while other believers take him to be a faithful preacher of the Word of God (the editor of the edition of the book we’re studying takes it to be Bunyan’s faithful preacher, see p. 295). Alexander Whyte says that “every minister of the gospel is an interpreter, and every evangelical church is an interpreter’s house…” (Whyte, Bunyan Characters, First Series, 76) On the other hand, Bunyan does talk about the need for “illumination” (p. 29) as allegorized by the “Candle.” The Interpreter seems to illumine, just like the Holy Spirit. As he explains the various scenes, he gives illumination. We cannot be absolutely certain.

 

The Man in the Iron Cage (34-35)

This episode is considered by some to be Bunyan’s darkest picture. What exactly is the point? Most take this to be someone like Francis Spira (lived in the 1500s).[5] He was a lawyer in Italy who became one of the Protestants. However, later on he recanted and went back to the Catholic church. This apostasy is recounted in A Relation of the Fearful Estate of Francis Spira. He was remorseful but found no hope. There is another example with which Bunyan was very familiar. One of his own friend in Bedford (John Child) also died hopeless like Spira. John Child was a Baptist minister who in great fear of persecution conformed to the Church of England. John Child ended up taking his own life on Oct. 15, 1684.

Each reference to Spira is used as an example of someone who was in an irrecoverable condition. In Pilgrim’s Progress he says, “I am now a Man of Despair, and am shut up in it, as in this Iron Cage. I cannot get out; O now I cannot.” In his Grace Abounding, Bunyan himself believed that he had come to this same predicament. On reading of Spira, he feared greatly and almost despaired.

Here is the Poem that comes with the Spira story. It introduces the frightening story.

Here see a soul that’s all despair; a man

All hell; a spirit all wounds; who can

A wound spirit bear?

Reader, would’st see, what may you never feel

Despair, racks, torments, whips of burning steel!

Behold, the man’s the furnace, in whose heart

Sin hath created hell; O in each part

What flames appear:

His thoughts all stings; words, swords;

Brimstone his breath;

His eyes flames; wishes curses, life a death;

A thousand deaths live in him, he not dead;

A breathing corpse in living, scalding lead.[6]

What this man in the cage represents are those men and women who have been sealed in their unbelief. In recounting this, Christian described this man in the cage to Piety as “the Man [who] had sinned himself quite out of hopes of Gods mercy” (p. 49). Bunyan says in another place, “The day of grace ends with some men before God takes them out of this world.”[7] See Ex. 9:12, 14; Deut. 29:18-19; 1 Sam. 28:4-6; Is. 66:4; Rom. 1:28-31; 2:3-5; Eph. 4:18-19; 2 Th. 2:10-12; 1 Tim. 4:2; Heb. 6:4-6 and Jude 5, 6, 13. Thomas Scott says, “But we should leave the doom of apparent apostates to God; and improve [i.e. make use of] their example, as a warning to ourselves and others, not to venture one step in so dangerous a path.”[8]

Let us remember Esau who “found no place for repentance, though he sought it with tears” (Heb. 12:17). Though we cannot determine who has fallen into this sad condition, we should take it to heart and not provoke God by our hard-heartedness. Heed Interpreter’s warning: “Let this mans misery be remembered by thee, and be an everlasting caution to thee.” (35)

 

Burden Loosed (37)

Remember, he was told “As to the burden, be content to bear it, until thou comest to the place of Deliverance; for there it will fall form thy back it self.” (29) Why did he bear it up to this time? Horner’s explanation is helpful here:

Having been directed by Good-will (Jesus Christ), burdened Christian arrives at the House of Interpreter (the Holy Spirit) for edification, in parallel with John 15:26. Here this new believer portrays Bunyan who, though still burdened, was likewise edified for his journey through the profitable instruction of Pastor John Gifford. So in Grace Abounding we are told, ‘At this time, also, I sat under the ministry of holy Mr. Gifford, whose doctrine, by God’s grace, was much for my stability.’ It is significant that the first room in Interpreter’s house displays a portrait of the godly pastor, as epitomized by Gifford, thus following very closely…the sequence of events described in Grace Abounding. For Christian, the burden remains while the balm of instruction is applied; and so he continues to struggle with temptation, troubling questions and fluctuations between hope and fear; and so it was the case with Bunyan until the cross came into clear view.

…Here Christian, like Bunyan as a believer who has at last come into a state of enlightenment, stability  and assurance, gains a much clearer understanding of the atonement, with all its attendant benefits, and especially that of the saving substitutionary atonement of Jesus Christ. Thus the burden of doubt falls away…Hence it would appear that Bunyan incorporates his own testimony into the narrative of The Pilgrim’s Progress as a help to those who, like himself, have needlessly floundered. …” (Horner, 137-138)

Remember, Christian passed through the Wicket Gate, the Interpreter’s House, and then the Place of Deliverance. Not all Christians experience it that way and one need not necessarily go through the same sequence. One writer says, “Bunyan symbolically intimated that in his opinion a longer or shorter period of time will elapse between coming to Christ and possessing the comfort and assurance that one’s sins are forgiven.” (Pieter de Vries cited in Horner, 140)


[1] Spurgeon says, “Bunyan alludes to the fact that, when souls are just upon the verge of salvation, they are usually assailed by the most violent temptations. …They are seeking the Saviour; they have begun to pray; they are anxious to believe on the Lord Jesus Christ; yet they are meeting with difficulties such as they never knew before, and they are almost at their wits’ end.” (Pictures from Pilgrim’s Progress, 67)

[2] Note, Christian has already met him, Evangelist.

[3] “…they must have all their good things now, they cannot stay till next Year; that is, until the next World, for their Portion of good.” (31)

[4] Note, “…that it is hard for the tempted to see how this work of Grace is maintained in the soul” (33).

[5] The dagger notation to this Oxford edition indicates this (p. 296). Bunyan refers to Spira at least five times in the course of his writings. For a superb overview of Spira and Bunyan, see Barry Horner, John Bunyan’s Pilgrim’s Progress: Themes and Issues (Auburn, MA: Evangelical Press, 2003), 223-235.

[6] Cited in Horner, Themes and Issues, 230.

[7] Bunynan, Works (Offor ed.), 3:579.

[8] Bunyan, The Pilgrim’s Progress…, with original notes by Thomas Scott (Hartford: Silas Andrus, 1830), 53.

Proverbs 2

Proverbs 2:1-22

Verses 1-5 encourages us to seek wisdom and vv. 5-9 is the answer. Again the theme is hungering for wisdom. Though this may be directed to the young, it pertains to all of us. The father here instructs his son to heed his counsel. It is wisdom beckoning us to heed God’s word. The two work together.

 

2:1-4 — 1 My son, if you receive my words and treasure up my commandments with you, 2 making your ear attentive to wisdom and inclining your heart to understanding; 3 yes, if you call out for insight and raise your voice for understanding, 4 if you seek it like silver and search for it as for hidden treasures,

This is taken to be the father instructing his son to follow the path of wisdom (cf. Waltke). That is probably true. It is also wisdom speaking through the father instructing us to follow her path of wisdom.

Derek Kidner makes an insightful observation. Whereas wisdom clamored to be heard in 1:20, now the pupil must clamor for her.  Wisdom is not calling for us to speculate in the dark. In verse 1, wisdom instructs us to receive her words and treasure [store up] her commands.

Verse 2 could be translated as “by making your ear attentive…” (cf. Waltke, 213 n.1), that is, we receive and treasure God’s word by making our ear attentive to wisdom and inclining our heart to understand. The individual’s heart must be disposed or inclined toward wisdom. The person cannot merely tolerate God’s Word or simply register its existence as if that is the only thing God requires.

Verses 3-4 expand upon the same point. Ardent efforts are enjoined; resolute pursuits are called upon. William Arnot aptly stated, “The zeal of Mammon’s worshippers rebukes the servants of the living God.” We have read of many men and families who ventured into the West to find Gold. Several lost their lives in the pursuit of fleeting treasure. Juan Ponce de León searched for the rumored fountain of youth in the Bahamas (ended in Florida); Hernán Cortés burned his ships in Mexico so as to induce his soldiers to be committed to his cause. People give themselves to their gods and causes. God calls us to desire his wisdom as silver and hidden treasure (she is worth more, 3:14 and 16:16, “How much better to get wisdom than gold! To get understanding is to be chosen rather than silver.”).

Charles Bridges believes these descriptions are exhibited in our prayers. Our ardent prayers manifest such characteristics. “Earthly wisdom is gained by study; heavenly wisdom by prayer. Study may form a Biblical scholar; prayer puts the heart under a heavenly tutorage, and therefore forms the wise and spiritual Christian.” (Bridges, 14) Furthermore, because wisdom is founded on receiving God’s word and commands, this earnest searching must be exhibited in our study of God’s Word.

 

2:5-9 —5 then you will understand the fear of the LORD and find the knowledge of God. 6 For the LORD gives wisdom; from his mouth come knowledge and understanding; 7 he stores up sound wisdom for the upright; he is a shield to those who walk in integrity, 8 guarding the paths of justice and watching over the way of his saints. 9 Then you will understand righteousness and justice and equity, every good path;

If we earnestly clamor for this heavenly wisdom, then we will find: “you will understand the fear of the LORD and find the knowledge of God.” This is a remarkable statement because fearing the Lord is the beginning of wisdom and we learn that an earnest searching after God’s wisdom will help us to rightly fear God and know Him. This understanding of God comes by receiving His Word.

Furthermore, we are told that God is the one who gives this wisdom, knowledge of Himself, an understanding of His ways. Wisdom is not something plucked by human effort; mere effort cannot arrest it. It is something God gives; He gives “sound wisdom” to the upright. Wisdom is not imparted to the unrighteous but those who receive His word and live uprightly. “Because the LORD alone has access to wisdom (Job 28:12-28) and gave it birth from his very being (Prov. 8:22-24), he alone gives wisdom (cf. Dan. 2:21-22).” (Waltke) George Lawson says, “It is plain that those who employ themselves in the diligent pursuit of wisdom, have been already blessed with some degree of true knowledge; for how could they value so highly that with which they were altogether unacquainted? He is already wise, who prefers wisdom to every earthly object; and he shall be wise still, for to him that hath shall be given, and he shall have more abundantly.” (Lawson, 31)

Verses 7-8 pile up the practical and moral benefits of God’s wisdom. God will protect those whom He blesses. “God’s protection is not a reward extraneous to the knowledge, but rather a consequence intrinsic to it.” (cited in Waltke) Wisdom and uprightness, integrity, and saintliness go together. Wisdom is not abstract but exhibits or demonstrates itself by godly characteristics. God will protect us through this difficult dark world.

Verse 9 reveals the implications this wisdom will have on the righteous. As God gives us wisdom (v. 5) and protects us (vv. 7, 8), we can begin to understand the proper paths in life, that is, “righteousness and justice and equity.” That is, “wisdom brings ethical enlightenment” (Longman).  “The internalized divine wisdom and knowledge enable the disciple to discern the right, just, and fair that the LORD commits himself to protect.” (Waltke)

This is what we need in this world— what is the proper path? How do we discern which way to go? With so many choices, we need to be able to understand “every good path.” God promises us that if we receive His words and treasure his commandments by inclining ourselves to better know and apply them, he will enable us to walk in the good path. This what wisdom promise.

 

2:10-15 — 10 for wisdom will come into your heart, and knowledge will be pleasant to your soul; 11 discretion will watch over you, understanding will guard you, 12 delivering you from the way of evil, from men of perverted speech, 13 who forsake the paths of uprightness to walk in the ways of darkness, 14 who rejoice in doing evil and delight in the perverseness of evil, 15 men whose paths are crooked, and who are devious in their ways.

These verses expand upon the point begun in v. 9. God’s gift of wisdom will aid us and God’s wisdom will sit well within us — “pleasant to your souls.” (v. 10) That is, God’s saints love God’s ways and His ways are not swallowed like bitter medicine but embraced as something pleasant.

God’s wisdom will become a part of us and it will help us. “The process is that wisdom and knowledge, when they become your own way of thinking, and your acquired taste (10), will make the talk and interests of evil men alien to you (12-15).” (Kidner) The impact of this wisdom leads us to take notice of and forsake the paths of unrighteousness. That is, saints will see the paths to be clear; they will immediately avoid those paths that are crooked. One of the effects is that we won’t fall into the wrong crowd or follow those who forsake the Lord. “The protection takes the form of extrication, removal from association with a certain type of person.” (Longman) Remember, the choice is clear and simple to the righteous because they have cried out to God for wisdom and have treasured His commandments. But that is not the case with everyone.

Some find the choice difficult. The way of evil men seems promising, at times pleasant, and some times praiseworthy. It appears that way to those who do not have God’s wisdom. Therefore, those who fall into bad company are not mere victims. Their wayward naïve lifestyle has led them to the foolish paths they chose; they have, as it were, sown the seeds of their own destruction. They did not seek wisdom and in times of critical choices, they fell into “the way of evil.” May God keep us from “men of perverted speech.”

Shunning evil and evil men does not mean we are to avoid unbelievers (cf. 1Cor. 5:10). We must consider our own strengths and weaknesses in these matters. Some are easily led astray by the influence of one person while others can withstand a thousand. Either way, each saint must discern what is right and follow it for the Lord’s sake. May the Lord preserve us.

 

2:16-19 — 16 So you will be delivered from the forbidden woman, from the adulteress with her smooth words, 17 who forsakes the companion of her youth and forgets the covenant of her God; 18 for her house sinks down to death, and her paths to the departed; 19 none who go to her come back, nor do they regain the paths of life.

Part of wisdom’s protection is from sexual sins. There are those men and women who will lead the young one astray into immorality. Here is something we often overlook. We tend to consider falling into immorality as a matter of weak strength, lack of will, strong overpowering desires, etc. But how did some one come to this? Proverbs teaches us that preservation from these sins is rooted in our love of wisdom, of God, and in what we treasure. There are perverse men and women who will seduce us — the righteous are protected from them. Sexual sins are not unrelated to our moral constitution and wisdom — the two are related. Lack wisdom and we can even fall into these sins. Possess wisdom as the Lord gives and He will preserve us from them. Proverbs 22:14 says, “The mouth of an adulteress is a deep pit; He who is cursed of the LORD will fall into it.”

Hubbard is therefore very correct: “What we have, then, in verses 16-20 is not an isolated warning about fornication or adultery but a further description of wisdom’s ability to serve as shield and guard (vv. 7-8) — ‘to deliver’ (v. 16) — in life’s temptation. Wisdom’s power is the chief subject, not the wanton’s wiles.” (Hubbard) Some 65 verses are given to this immoral woman. It will be the subject of ch. 5-7. “This understanding and prudence is an antidote against the poisonous infection of evil men and strange women.” (Lawson, 38)

With the growing number of immoral places (the so called “adult entertainment” centers or “gentlemen’s clubs” along with myriads of immoral facilities) in our country and around the world, we must wonder if the Lord is not judging our land. Surely this is a curse upon our neighborhood and nation.

It would not be stretching the meaning of the text to suggest that Solomon was also alluding to religious compromise. Adultery serves as analogy to spiritual adultery. We need protection from both.

 

2:20-22 — 20 So you will walk in the way of the good and keep to the paths of the righteous. 21 For the upright will inhabit the land, and those with integrity will remain in it, 22 but the wicked will be cut off from the land, and the treacherous will be rooted out of it.

As God’s wisdom protects us from evil men and wicked women, so it enables us to walk with the righteous. The final result of wisdom’s protection is that we will live to inhabit the land and not be cut off prematurely. “Failure to heed wisdom’s call leads either to premature death or to a life so void of happiness as to be a living death in which none of the God-given blessing of the ‘earth’… is available to lend any joy or meaning to life.” (Hubbard) [The picture is concrete and envisions a land without the wicked. The fullness of this vision is accomplished when Christ comes back and establishes the New Heaven and Earth..] “Death is a kind messenger sent to the righteous by their heavenly Father, calling them to the possession of their eternal inheritance; to the wicked it is a messenger of wrath, summoning them to the abodes of misery.” (Lawson)

 

Proverbs 1:20-33

Proverbs 1:20-33

1:20-21 — Wisdom cries aloud in the street, in the markets she raises her voice; at the head of the noisy streets she cries out; at the entrance of the city gates she speaks:

Wisdom is personified and she goes out to the street, into the markets and cries out at the entrance of the city gates. The imagery is like a father (since elders sat at the gates) making every effort to reach the uncommitted masses with his teachings (cf. Waltke). One writer said, “Lady Wisdom is no gentle persuader. She shouts, pleads, scolds, reasons, threatens, warns, and even laughs (see vv. 24-33). Pulpit bashing and hell-fire preaching if ever there were! All quite unladylike; and nowadays also quite unfashionable, even frowned upon.” (cited in Waltke, 202)

Some commentators have likened this to Jesus Himself who was in the streets and fields preaching (cf. Bridges, Arnot). He is wisdom itself — “The eternal Son of God is not only wisdom in himself, He is ‘made unto us wisdom.’” (Arnot) Regarding the setting, Perowne says, “Just within the gate of an oriental city was the principal square, or open space, where public business was transacted and courts were held.”

 

1:22 — How long, O simple ones, will you love being simple? How long will scoffers delight in their scoffing and fools hate knowledge?

The phrase “How long…”  is a rhetorical question which assumes a statement. “It is not a true question but an implied statement: you have had long enough; you should have answer my call by now.” (Hubbard) It may assume the rejection of parental counsel (cf. Waltke).

The “simple ones” are committing themselves to simplicity. They are the unwary (Perowne), the young and naïve (Hubbard), the gullible (Waltke) etc. “But instead of embracing the teaching, the fledgling apostates love being gullible.” (Waltke) They love something that will destroy them; they edge closer to outright rebellion. “Her problem with these three groups of people is that they each relish their present state of ignorance. They not only tolerate it but also embrace it wholeheartedly, as communicated by the verbs ‘love’ …and ‘hold dear’ [delight]. “ (Longman)

So the gullible, the simple ones are mentioned with the scoffers and fools. The gullible can easily become like them. They hate knowledge and scoff at wisdom. Of the three, the simple ones are the most likely to heed the call; the mockers are the most hardened of the three.

It is important to note that Wisdom mentions the mockers and fools to show where they stand. This contrast is important for the simple ones. They must see that there are those who oppose wisdom and must make a decision. Will the simple be like the mockers and fools? Will she also mock? Will she also hate knowledge? The options are there but what will she do?

 

§1. There are people who have yet to choose the right path. They flirt with mischief and disaster; they are enamored with the world; they are not committed to the way of gospel holiness. They keep their options open.

§2. Solomon says that they “love” simplicity. Some simply do not want to “grow up” and become wise and discerning. Life is serious and we need what wisdom offers but the simple like the life of indolence and leisure — they do not wish to be serious but love what is naïve and simple, they love to be careless.

 

1:23 — If you turn at my reproof, behold, I will pour out my spirit to you; I will make my words known to you.

Even with this tendency to love simplicity, wisdom still beckons and promises. The gullible can still turn, he can still repent (the word can be translated as turn back or repent) and heed the reproof. “If they turn back, their action will in itself imply their repentance, for they will have humbled themselves and acknowledged that Wisdom is right and that they have been in the wrong in nursing their love to be careless and free of her discipline.” (Waltke)

Wisdom does not apologize for rebuking, for her reproof. She rebukes with a promise, namely, she will pour our her spirit on the simple ones (similar language to Joel 2:28) — “and thus be empowered to carry out the implications of the turning and to know more fully what wisdom wants to teach them” (Hubbard)

 

§1. Part of wisdom is to recognize that one had no wisdom and therefore has to turn back, to repent, of his ways. It does us no good to pretend we had not erred. Wisdom admits it walked in the way of folly.

§2. “Note the close connection between ‘spirit’ and ‘words’ — a connection sound theology has always made in refusing to choose one above the other or to play them against each other.” (Hubbard)

 

1:24-27 — Because I have called and you refused to listen, have stretched out my hand and no one has heeded, because you have ignored all my counsel and would have none of my reproof, I also will laugh at your calamity; I will mock when terror strikes you, when terror strikes you like a storm and your calamity comes like a whirlwind, when distress and anguish come upon you.

The invitation to turn and repent is short; the warnings against not turning are longer. Chapter 8 develops the promises and benefits of yielding to wisdom. What have the simple ones done? They have “refused to listen” and have not “heeded”; they have “ignored” Wisdom’s counsel and “would have none of my reproof.” Their choice was deliberate. The decision was thorough and resolute. The tender promises will no longer be heard. They will hear the righteous laughter of Wisdom. “Truth has a harsh edge, and Wisdom does not dull it.” (Waltke)

This may strike us as being overly harsh. Yet, this sarcasm is righteous. One does not have unlimited opportunities. Remember, “TODAY is the day of salvation…” “The ask-receive, seek-find pattern has time limits built into it in both Testaments (Isa. 55;6; Matt. 7:7).” (Hubbard) [2 Corinthians 6:2 For he says, “In a favorable time I listened to you, and in a day of salvation I have helped you.” Behold, now is the favorable time; behold, now is the day of salvation. Isaiah 55:6 “Seek the LORD while he may be found; call upon him while he is near; Matthew 7:7 “Ask, and it will be given to you; seek, and you will find; knock, and it will be opened to you.]

Waltke says, “Wisdom does not laugh at disaster, but at the triumph of what is right over what is wrong when your disaster happens…” (Waltke, 207) That is, Wisdom rejoices over God’s righteous judgment on evil (cf. Hubbard denies God’s active role in this — it is “the order coded by God into the creation”). Waltke also adds, “Wisdom rejoices in turning the present upside-down world rightside up, when wisdom overturns folly, righteousness outs wickedness, knowledge overcomes ignorance, humility topples pride, and life swallows up death.” (Waltke)

Longman explains, “Woman Wisdom comes across in this speech as angry and unyielding. She shows no mercy to those who come to their senses in the midst of the punishment that their foolish action brings on them. However, the intention of this speech is to spur present action. She does not want them to wait till they are in the midst of their suffering, but she wants them to turn to her right away to avoid the pain.”

 

1:28-31 — Then they will call upon me, but I will not answer; they will seek me diligently but will not find me. Because they hated knowledge and did not choose the fear of the LORD, would have none of my counsel and despised all my reproof, therefore they shall eat the fruit of their way, and have their fill of their own devices.

If Wisdom’s laughter seems harsh, then these verses almost seem incomprehensible. Wisdom will be vindicated; time will run out and her ways will be shown to be right. One does not have endless opportunities to heed wisdom; choices made can lead to death unless the person repents. It is too late to turn when the consequences of folly come upon the simple. What they did to her, she will do to them. They did not heed her but despised her; they mocked her and hated her counsel. Now the table has turned on them —“they shall eat the fruit of their way, and have their fill of their own devices.” Bridges says, “Prayer, once omnipotent, will then be powerless.” (Bridges, 11)

It must be noted that the refusal in question is one that is substantive and resolute. The mocker is the one who chose not to fear the Lord and “would have none my counsel and despised all my reproof.” The person in question is not the one who has made some foolish choices and has wandered off occasionally. The person envisioned in these verses is the one who has consciously and repeatedly refused wisdom. Such a person will receive his just recompense (see §2). He is the one who continually sinned in time who will fall into hell in eternity. God has not ceased to be gracious while we live nor does He desire our death (Ezekiel 18:23, Have I any pleasure in the death of the wicked, declares the Lord GOD, and not rather that he should turn from his way and live?) but his grace will not extend beyond the grave.

§1. In our evangelical situation, we tend to think of limitless opportunities. Everybody can always make a fresh start. So these words in Proverbs seem to be very unevangelical. God is not always going to extend His mercy — He is not merciful forever. Hell is the monument of God’s righteousness and man’s rebellion. So, we must reckon with the consequences of our actions.

§2. Some may say that we have all acted as this fool. So how long and how often can we refuse God before He will turn deaf to us? God is not obligated to hear any of us. The question assumes that God is obligated to be gracious to us at every turn. He is not. He extends mercy and pleads through His Word. But if He chooses to turn us over to our evil passion and consign us to our wicked ways, then we have only ourselves to blame. These verses are given as a warning. We must not entertain the notion that we can safely sin and safely resist God. If fear of the future judgment causes us to be wise and turn to the Lord, then for that we thank God. If the love of God and His goodness woo us, then for that we also thank Him. It has been prayed, “Save, Lord, by love or fear.”

     

    1:32-33 — For the simple are killed by their turning away, and the complacency of fools destroys them; but whoever listens to me will dwell secure and will be at ease, without dread of disaster.”

    The gullible turned away from Wisdom (God) and fools are destroyed on account of their sense of security, prosperity, ease, etc. “So the complacency of fools (or dolts), due to their false feelings of security, causes them to fail to take precautions against the inevitable judgment bound up in their folly, and so it will destroy them…” (Waltke).

    On the other hand, the one who obeys or listens to Wisdom “will dwell secure and will be at ease, without dread of disaster.” It is in contrast to the fool. The fool thought he had this; he did not. The one who listened to Wisdom actually secured this.

     

    §1. “And, oh! be it remembered, that every inattention, every willful neglect, is a step towards this fearful apostasy. The word gradually becomes a burden, then a scorn.” (Bridges) Let us heed God’s Word.

    §2. The promises in v. 33 do not mean worldly security but true security in the Lord. We will dwell confident because our conscience is clear and because the Lord is near. We trust not in our wit or wisdom but in God’s Wisdom and Word.

     

    Proverbs 1:8-19

    Proverbs 1:8-19

    1:8-9 — 8 Hear, my son, your father’s instruction, and forsake not your mother’s teaching, 9 for they are a graceful garland for your head and pendants for your neck.

    The first thing Solomon teaches us in the path of wisdom is the call to heed parental instruction. This is very significant. One, it follows right after the introduction in which Solomon offers wisdom. This effectively makes it important because of its location. Two, after fearing God, wisdom calls us to accept instruction from our parents (contrary to a fool who despises wisdom and instruction, v. 7).

    Our culture worships all things young. Parents are tolerated at best; they are no longer important or necessary. The Bible on the other hand indicates that one of the first steps we are to take in order to be wise is to heed the instruction of parents. This is in accordance with the first commandment with a promise (Eph. 6:2; cf. 1Tim. 5:4). In hearing and not forsaking them, we will make us spiritually beautiful: “Obedience makes a person delightfully outstanding to others and gives one something to cherish and value for oneself.” (Hubbard)

    God is saying that the child (“my son”) must hear their fathers and must not forsake their mothers teaching or law (tr:îAT). God is telling the young not to forsake the instruction of the parents. “That both parents are mentioned is a tribute to the prominent role of Israel’s mothers. We find no similar reference to mother as teacher in Babylonian or Egyptian wisdom literature.” (Hubbard, 49)

    Verse 9 is the motivation. Waltke says these are “symbols of honor and life that can hardly be disregarded.” Furthermore, “they [the teachings] are the adornments; the adornments are not something future and extrinsic to them.…all children who obey their godly parents and embrace the teachings of this book wear the teachings as heroes wore ‘the great wreath.” (Waltke, 187-8)

    1. It assumes that parents instruct their children. George Lawson says, “It is here supposed that parents will instruct their children. They are monsters rather than parents, who do not love the fruit of their own bodies. Love will dispose persons to do all the good they can to the objects of it; and the best thing that can be done for children, is to teach them the fear of the Lord.” (p. 8)

    2. Unto what age should a child heed his parents’ advice? Bridges says, “Neither age nor rank gives any claim for exemption. Joseph — when ripe in years, the head of a family, and the first Lord in Egypt— bowed before his father’s feet. (Gen xlvi. 29; xlviii. 12.) Solomon, in the glory of his crown, forgot not the respect justly due to his mother. [cf. 1K. 2:19, 20; cf. also Esther 2:20] Nor were the crown upon his head, and the chain of gold about Joseph’s neck… so graceful as this ornament of filial humility.”

     

    1:10-14 — The first teaching of the parents is to avoid bad company. He is saying, Regard your parents and resist your peers. This scenario presents itself to everyone. Every young man or woman is confronted with peer pressure — with opportunities to run with a crowd against the parent’s judgment.  “The son’s allegiance to the family’s inherited worldview must be sharply delineated from that of the gang, who seek to draw him into their corruption.” (Waltke, 188)

    1:10 — My son, if sinners entice you, do not consent.

    Sinners in Proverbs are those who have already chosen the path of folly and sin. They love company and love to mislead. Their solicitations require acquiescence; the young son must consent, reply affirmatively, accept the invitation, etc. He may be misled but he is not misled against his will. “Eve consented, before she plucked the fruit; David, before he committed the act of sin (cf. Bridges). “If the temptation prevail, charge it not on God; no — nor on the devil. As the worst he can do, he can only tempt, he cannot force us, to sin. When he has plied us with his utmost power, and most subtle artifice, it is at the choice of our own will, whether we yield or no. (See Jam. i. 13-15)” (Bridges, 6)

     

    1:11-14 — 11 If they say, “Come with us, let us lie in wait for blood; let us ambush the innocent without reason; 12 like Sheol let us swallow them alive, and whole, like those who go down to the pit; 13 we shall find all precious goods, we shall fill our houses with plunder; 14 throw in your lot among us; we will all have one purse”-

    These are the sinners’ solicitations. Solomon is stating their words in their truest terms. They often come with deception: “Come, let us pick the pocket of some covetous miser, who has made himself rich by cunning, and scraped money together by such cowardly practices, as cannot expose him to the vengeance of the law.” (cf. Lawson) In other words, the words are often seductive and do not tell the whole story but the meaning is as the parents have stated it.

    Verse 13 reveals what will be gained. Riches will come but unlawfully. All sin and all seductions have some “good” in view, that is, one will gain something from it (satisfaction, pleasure, money, power, revenge, etc.) Verse 14 promises camaraderie — the person will be one of the gang with one purse. Easy money with promised friendship — who can resist? With money, the young man can get what he wants; with friends, he can use it in “happy” company. This is the way of the world. Waltke notes, “Sinners love wealth and use people; saints love people and use wealth to help others.” (193)

     

    1:15 — my son, do not walk in the way with them; hold back your foot from their paths,

    Parents warn against this sin. They portrayed the scenario; they stated the reasons of sinners and now they give their wise and hearty advice. Don’t go there. Stay away. Notice the words, parents are saying, “Don’t even go with them.” Some flatter themselves with the thought that they can resist; they want only to be with their companions — don’t walk with them. Waltke says “hold back your foot from their paths” means something like, “do not experiment with their addiction.” To walk in their paths is to deviate from paths of righteousness.

     

    1:16 — for their feet run to evil, and they make haste to shed blood.

    Lawson says, “Let us never forget the evil that is in sin. However men may dress it out in beautiful colours, it is the very quintessence of naughtiness.” These sinners are determined; they run and make haste to do these things; they are bent on wickedness.

    Parents need to instruct their children as to the true nature of certain ways. We must not downplay or overstate it but any path that deviates from God must be painted for what it is.

     

    1:17-18 — 17 For in vain is a net spread in the sight of any bird, 18 but these men lie in wait for their own blood; they set an ambush for their own lives.

    This gang of sinners promises much but are unaware of the very ambush they set for themselves. “No mention is made of pained consciences lives that stew in regret, heartache for friends and family, fear of being caught by authorities or betrayed by comrades who want the one purse for themselves, as did Judas in the apostolic company.” (Hubbard) In effect, these criminals are more stupid than birds! “But the lying-in-wait and the secret lurking which they described so vividly in verse 11 are the height of stupidity, since the sinners themselves are their own prey, the ultimate victims of their own feet; the very feet that run in the eagerness to work their evil crimes, violently hurrying to shed blood (v. 16) are maimed by their avid greed.” (Hubbard) Waltke notes how the father used their own words but has changed the victim. The phrases “for their own blood” and “for their own lives” are emphatic — they themselves are their own victims. “They look like they will pillage others, but in the outcome, it is they who will be pillaged.” (Longman)

     

    1:19 — Such are the ways of everyone who is greedy for unjust gain; it takes away the life of its possessors.

    This is the lesson of the parent’s instruction. Those who are so greedy for unjust gain, for illegal profit, unrighteous earnings, etc. will lose their souls. “The unjust gain clings to the criminal and eventually destroys him. Jesus draws a similar universal: ‘All who live by the sword will die by the sword’ (Matt. 26:52). In sum, this aphorism articulates the book’s fundamental concept of deed-consequence: sin begets harm (cf. Gal. 6:7).” (Waltke) “The sages are not against the pursuit of profits through honest, hard work. Many of the proverbs that follow actually encourage hard work with the intention of gaining profits.” (Longman)

    Koch is cited (by Waltke on p. 194) as saying, “A man’s deeds cling to him as it were, wrapping themselves around him in an invisible domain, which one day is transformed into a corresponding condition or state, and then recoils on the doer.” Waltke prefers the “deed-destiny nexus upheld by God, the knowledge of which is necessary for wisdom.”

    Proverbs 1:1-7

    Proverbs 1:1-7

    Hubbard gives a good overview of Proverbs: “The bulk of Proverbs divides into two major kinds of literature: instructive speeches, chapters 1-9; wisdom sayings, chapters 10-31. The speeches had as their main purpose to state every possible reason why wisdom should be valued and folly despised.” (43) Wisdom will beseech the reader to consider her ways. That will be the theme of chapters 1-9.

     

    1:1 — The proverbs of Solomon, son of David, king of Israel:

    Solomon was the last king of all Israel (966-926 BC). God has specially gifted Solomon for this task and these are his proverbs in addition to ones he collected into his book that were penned by other writers (30:1; 31:1). Hezekiah also played a role in conserving these proverbs (25:1, “These also are proverbs of Solomon which the men of Hezekiah king of Judah copied.”). We have all read of Solomon’s gift of wisdom. The following is a summary account of the fame of his wisdom (1K. 4:29-34):

    29 And God gave Solomon wisdom and understanding beyond measure, and breadth of mind like the sand on the seashore, 30 so that Solomon’s wisdom surpassed the wisdom of all the people of the east and all the wisdom of Egypt. 31 For he was wiser than all other men, wiser than Ethan the Ezrahite, and Heman, Calcol, and Darda, the sons of Mahol, and his fame was in all the surrounding nations. 32 He also spoke 3,000 proverbs, and his songs were 1,005. 33 He spoke of trees, from the cedar that is in Lebanon to the hyssop that grows out of the wall. He spoke also of beasts, and of birds, and of reptiles, and of fish. 34 And people of all nations came to hear the wisdom of Solomon, and from all the kings of the earth, who had heard of his wisdom.

    A proverb is a pithy wise saying about various things. It communicates lessons on life. These proverbs are ultimately rooted in God (see above; v. 7) and as a result, they can only make full sense in terms of God.

    1:2 — To know wisdom and instruction, to understand words of insight,

    These verses give us the purpose of this book. Each verse begins with “to” or “in order to” (Dl) except in v. 5. These proverbs were collected to know wisdom, etc. “To know” here means something more than mere mental knowledge acquisition. Given 2:1-4, it means personal internalization of wisdom and experiencing it in one’s life. Wisdom “is the broadest, most inclusive term available to depict the combination of observation, obedience, careful planning, prudent conduct, and sensitivity to God’s will that Israel’s wise treasured and taught…” (Hubbard, 45)

    This wisdom cannot be possessed without instruction, which is “the means of gaining it.” (Bridges, 2) This word “instruction” is used more than thirty times and the meaning includes correction and discipline.

    The person also cannot gain wisdom and instruction without an ability to understand. So Solomon says, “to understand words of insight” (NJKV, “to perceive the words of instruction”).  Wisdom and instruction need to be understood, perceived, or apprehended. It is the ability “to discern the differences at stake in the choices being weighed.” (Hubbard)

    1:3 — to receive instruction in wise dealing, in righteousness, justice, and equity

    The goal cannot be accomplished without accepting or receiving the instruction of wisdom or “instruction in wise dealing, in righteousness, justice, and equity.” The verb means to “take, grasp, seize (manually)” or “to take away with one,” etc. This “wise dealing” or “instruction in wisdom” is qualified as “in righteousness, justice, and equity.” It reveals the ethical nature of wisdom (because not all wisdom is good).  Adam and Eve thought disobedience would make them wise (“the tree was to be desired to make one wise” Gen. 3:6). That kind of craftiness, shrewdness, wisdom from below is not to be desired.

    1:4 — to give prudence to the simple, knowledge and discretion to the youth-

    The purpose of the book is to give prudence (hm’_r>[‘) to the simple, young, or naïve (‘to be inexperienced, be naïve”).[1] “The opposite of the simpleminded person is not the wise but the prudent person, and this is the characteristic that the wisdom of Proverbs seeks to provide to the naïve reader: The simpleminded person is in a much better place than a fool… or a mocker…. [because] they are teachable.” (Longman) The contrast seems to be between being gullible and being shrewd.

    The young needs knowledge and discretion (“caginess” Waltke, i.e. caution). That will be imparted by these proverbs. The youth are often considered naïve, gullible, simpleminded, etc. They are the target audience though not exclusively.

    1:5 — Let the wise hear and increase in learning, and the one who understands obtain guidance,

    Even the wise may still learn. “For a truly wise man is one, not who has attained, but who knows that he ‘has not attained,’ and is pressing onward to perfection.” (Bridges) The wise person “already participates in the wisdom program, but the introduction reminds the reader that even such an advance person can benefit from reflection on the instructions to follow.” (Longman) “Since by nature the wises hear and obey, each new hearing of the proverbs increases their corpus of knowledge…” (Waltke)

    KJV has “wise counsel”; it means “accurate guidance” or more literally, “sound steering of the right course.” (Hubbard) In hearing and receiving the proverbs, the instructions, the man of understanding will be able to rightly steer through life. He will see which way to go. It will be like having wise counselors always at his side guiding him. So this book is not just for the simple; it is for everyone. None of us are too wise for it! A child likes its simple and concrete advices; an adult is drawn to its profound simplicity and its realistic estimation of life.

    1:6 — to understand a proverb and a saying, the words of the wise and their riddles.

    Wisdom calls everyone to understand “a proverb, a saying, the words of the wise and their riddles.” “Riddles are teasing questions that are clear enough to give clues to their solution and cryptic enough to throw the careless off track…” (Hubbard)

    Riddles and sayings of the wise are not teachings per se. They demand insight and decision. “Ps. 78:1-2 labels that psalm’s recitation of Israel’s history not only as ‘teaching’ but also as ‘proverb’ and ‘riddle’ because it asks its audience to make an intuitive critical judgment of their own behavior in light of that history.” (Waltke) That is, when we give our attention to these things, we will begin to penetrate the seeming riddles and enigmas of these statements; the difficult sayings, the perplexing truths, etc. will begin to make sense to us.

    This means, after we begin to understand and incorporate these truths, these proverbs, these words of the wise, etc. will begin to work their way in and through our lives.

    1:7 — The fear of the LORD is the beginning of knowledge; fools despise wisdom and instruction.

    After giving us the purpose, the preamble, we are now given the foundation for the rest of the book. It is the “quintessential expression of the basic spiritual grammar for understanding the book.” (Waltke)

    The fear of the Lord is “foundational to knowledge, which here functions as a close synonym to wisdom. In this way, the book acknowledges the radically relational and theocentric nature of knowledge/wisdom.” (Longman) The “beginning” means something is the principal thing, the chief thing. God is the foundation of all knowledge, all wisdom. In Prov. 20:12, we read, “The hearing ear and the seeing eye, the LORD has made them both.” Fearing God “is the first thought that makes all other thoughts fall into place” (Longman).

    The opposite of this is found in fools. Fools do not fear God and as a result lack wisdom. They lack wisdom because they “despise wisdom and instruction.” Wisdom and instruction are the two things first offered to us in v. 2. Fools “willfully make the corrupt moral choice to refuse the sage’s moral teachings.” (Waltke)

    Have we not noticed this? The one who needs wisdom resists it while the one who is wise wants more. True wisdom begins and ends in God.


    [1] The “young” or naïve person was anyone up to the age of thirty. He was fully accountable at the age of twenty (cf. Num. 1:3, 18; 14:29; 26:2, 4) but was unable to serve in the temple until thirty years old (Num. 4:3). cf. Waltke, 178.

    Proverbs, An Introduction

    Proverbs

    Introduction

    Very few commentaries had been written on Proverbs until recently. Now, more and more scholars are studying OT Wisdom literature and significant commentaries have emerged.[1] It is by far the “most practical” books of the OT. Its sage advice, pithy style, and clear exhortations make it the favorite book of many. Most of Proverbs often have direct and immediate relevance to all readers.

    Interestingly, the book is rarely preached though often studied. The reason may be due to its very strength. If it is so eminently practical and clear, what more needs to be said? There is also the difficulty of its arrangements — the verses often appear to be a series of unrelated series of exhortations and statements. This would make for difficult preaching. Remember, this is one of the books on which Calvin did not write a commentary.  Another reason is the danger of moralism. The book seems to stress how we ought to act more than what God has done for us (cf. Hubbard, 17).

    The Latin Vulgate uses the title, Liber Proverbiorum. It is the translation of the Hebrew misle (a form of masal, which means “proverb”). The Greek OT (LXX) uses paroimiai which can be translated as parable or proverb. A proverb is a short, pithy observation, admonition, warning, prohibition, and wise saying.[2]

    Overview[3]

    1-9, A fatherly approach: exhortations for the young.

    10:1-22:16, A plain man’s approach: Solomon’s collection of sentence-sayings. Life’s regularities, oddities, dangers and delights, noted, compared and evaluated.

    22:17-24:22 and 24:23-34, More fatherly teachings: two groups of wise men’s exhortations.

    25-29, More sentence-sayings; gleanings from Solomon, compiled by Hezekiah’s men. [25:1, “These also are proverbs of Solomon which the men of Hezekiah king of Judah copied.”]

    30, An observer’s approach: musings on the hidden Creator and on the idiosyncrasies of his creatures. [30:1, “The words of Agur son of Jakeh. The oracle.”]

    31, A womanly approach: a mother’s home-truths (1-9); a wife’s example (10-31).

    Wisdom

    A dominant theme which runs through the book is the theme of wisdom. Wisdom is explicitly stated while her existence is always implied. Wisdom generally means “masterful understanding,” “skill,” “expertise.” Wisdom is inseparable from knowledge. “In Proverbs, hokma [wisdom] denotes mastery over experience through the intellectual, emotional, and spiritual state of knowing existentially the deed-destiny nexus — that is, to act on moral-spiritual knowledge out of its internalization (1:2; 2:1-5), thereby enabling its possessor to cope with enigma and adversity, to tear down strongholds, and thus to promote the life of an individual and/or a community (21:22; cf. 24:5; Eccl. 7:19; 9:13-16). A person could memorize the book of Proverbs and still lack wisdom if it id not affect his heart, which informs behavior.”[4]

    In Proverbs, wisdom is pitted against the fatal charms of the whore and the adulteress and against folly itself. “There is presented to us the figure of Wisdom as the soul’s true bride, true counselor, true hostess, and as the very offspring of the Creator.”[5]

    Wisdom, in these chapters, obviously prepares the way for Jesus Christ who is the Wisdom of God (1Cor. 1:24). Wisdom is personified as a Lady crying out (“Wisdom cries aloud in the street…” 1:20). We find wisdom is deeply rooted in God (8:22ff.), comes from God (2:6, “The Lord gives wisdom”) and is related to one’s attitude to God (9:10, “The fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom”).

    The Benefits of Wisdom

    There are great benefits in having wisdom. It is the fool who overlooks or disregards this. Several verses bring this point out. Wisdom is its own reward of course but possessing her soothes the soul and satisfies the person.

    2:10-12, “…for wisdom will come into your heart, and knowledge will be pleasant to your soul; 11 discretion will watch over you, understanding will guard you, 12 delivering you from the way of evil, from men of perverted speech,:

    3:7-8, “Be not wise in your own eyes; fear the LORD, and turn away from evil. It will be healing to your flesh and refreshment to your bones.”

    9:11, “For by me your days will be multiplied, and years will be added to your life.”

    10:23, “Doing wrong is like a joke to a fool, but wisdom is pleasure to a man of understanding.”

    Wisdom Resides in God

    In 8:22, we see Wisdom personified and perhaps a reference to Christ Himself. God possessed or acquired (ynIn”q’) wisdom from the beginning (NIV is not the best on this). “Wisdom is both older than the universe, and fundamental to it. Not a speck of matter (26b), not a trace of order (29), came into existence but by wisdom” (Kidner, Proverbs, 78)

    God Himself never acted without Wisdom; He was always there in the beginning with her; He possessed her and she has always dwelt with Him.

    JOB 28 asks where can wisdom be found— Job 28:23 “God understands the way to it, and he knows its place.” “Man’s remarkable success as a miner shows how clever and intelligent he is; but, for all that, he has failed completely to unearth wisdom.” (Andersen on Job, in TOTC)

    Wisdom Comes from God

    The Lord is able to give wisdom (2:6), “For the LORD gives wisdom; from his mouth come knowledge and understanding…” The Lord wants to give wisdom (1:20ff.; 8:1-11; 9:1-6).

    Unlike the solicitors of our generation who may or may not be selling something beneficial, here is one who solicits us and who benefits from this? You and I do! 9:12 says, “If you are wise, you are wise for yourself; if you scoff, you alone will bear it.”

    Remember, the Lord entreats us to entreat Him for wisdom. James 1:5 says,  “If any of you lacks wisdom, let him ask God, who gives generously to all without reproach, and it will be given him.”  Prov. 2:3-4 says, “and if you call out for insight and cry aloud for understanding, and if you look for it as for silver and search for it as for hidden treasure…” There is great danger of not heeding wisdom, the danger of not acquiring wisdom (1:23ff.)

    Wisdom is connected to God

    It says that the FEAR of the LORD is the beginning of WISDOM (9:10).  The word for “beginning” doesn’t just mean to start with the fear of the Lord and then graduate into something else. The word also suggests priority, its prominent position- it is first in importance and first in sequence. As one commentator said, the fear of God is both the ceiling and the foundation, namely, that it is our goal as well as our beginning. Job 28:28 says, “And he said to man, ‘Behold, the fear of the Lord, that is wisdom, and to turn away from evil is understanding.'”

    In other words, there is no wisdom without the fear of God; without that all gripping reverence for God and His ways, without that holy trembling before His infinite majesty-there simply is no wisdom.

    All our ways are related to God and He can thwart all human efforts. If this fear of the Lord does not guide our steps, then we act as fools since none of our labors can stand on their own. Proverbs 16:1-4 says, “The plans of the heart belong to man, but the answer of the tongue is from the LORD. 2 All the ways of a man are pure in his own eyes, but the LORD weighs the spirit. 3 Commit your work to the LORD, and your plans will be established. 4 The LORD has made everything for its purpose, even the wicked for the day of trouble. Also, 16:9 says, “The heart of man plans his way, but the LORD establishes his steps.” (16:33, “The lot is cast into the lap, but its every decision is from the LORD.”) “The fear of the Lord relativizes human wisdom, because the mysterious freedom of God can subvert human plans and purposes (16:1, 9; 19:21; 21:30-31; 27:1). Without the God of Israel, the best human wisdom becomes folly, because God alone holds the world and all outcomes in God’s hands (2 Sam 16:15-17:23; 1 Cor 1:18-31)” (The New Interpreter’s Bible, 5:33)

    Wisdom recognizes that all of life is related to God and therefore the pious heart orients itself to God and regulates his life in accordance with God’s ways. Faith is critical here. Though Proverbs does not explicitly state it, it nonetheless assumes it.

    …it is noteworthy that Proverbs, for all its emphasis on common sense, exalts faith above sagacity (3:5, 7: ‘Trust in the Lord with all thine heart; and upon thine own understanding lean not;…Be not wise in thine own eyes…’); and for all its advocacy of prudence it refuses prudence the last word. Planning, proper as it is (‘Plans are established by counsel: by wise guidance wage war’, 20:18)—planning is subject to God’s Yes or No (19:21: ‘Many are the plans in the mind of a man, but it is the purpose of Yahweh that will be established’); equipment guarantees nothing (21:31: ‘The horse is prepared against the day of battle: but safety is of the Lord’)… (Kidner, Proverbs, 33)


    [1] Four can be listed, from the newest to the oldest: Tremper Longman III, Proverbs, Baker Commentary on the Old Testament Wisdom and Psalms (Grand Rapids: Baker Academic, 2006); Bruce K. Waltke, The Book of Proverbs, Chapters 1-15, NICOT (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2004); Bruce K. Waltke, The Book of Proverbs, Chapters 15-31, NICOT (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2005); Roland E. Murphy, Proverbs, Word Biblical Commentary, vol. 22 (Nashville: Thomas Nelson Publishers, 1998); Raymond C. Van Leeuwen, The Book of Proverbs, NIB (Nashville: Abingdon, 1997).

    Also worth mentioning are Derek Kidner, The Proverbs, TOTC (Downers Grove: Inter-Varsity Press, 1964); D. A. Hubbard, Proverbs, The Communicator’s Commentary (Dallas: Word, 1989); Duane A. Garrett, Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, Song of Solomon, The New American Commentary, vol. 14 (Nashville: Broadman Press, 1993). The standard liberal commentary is R. N. Whybray, Proverbs, The New Century Bible Commentary (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1994).

    [2] I used Tremper Longman III, Proverbs, 21.

    [3] This is taken from Derek Kidner, The Wisdom of Proverbs, Job & Ecclesiastes: An Introduction to Wisdom Literature (Downers Grove: IVP, 1985), 18.

    [4] Bruce K. Waltke, The Book of Proverbs, Chapters 1-15, NICOT (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2004), 77.

    [5] Kidner, The Wisdom of Proverbs, Job & Ecclesiastes, 22.

    The Larger Catechism, #69, pt. 1

    The Larger Catechism

    Questions 69

    69.       Q. What is the communion in grace which the members of the invisible church have with Christ?

    A. The communion in grace which the members of the invisible church have with Christ, is their partaking of the virtue of his mediation, in their justification,[283] adoption,[284] sanctification, and whatever else, in this life, manifests their union with him.[285]

    Scriptural Defense and Commentary

    [283] Romans 8:30. Moreover whom he did predestinate, them he also called: and whom he called, them he also justified: and whom he justified, them he also glorified. [284] Ephesians 1:5. Having predestinated us unto the adoption of children by Jesus Christ to himself, according to the good pleasure of his will. [285] 1 Corinthians 1:30. But of him are ye in Christ Jesus, who of God is made unto us wisdom, and righteousness, and sanctification, and redemption.

    Introduction

    Most commentators give very little attention to this question because it introduces the subsequent questions on justification, adoption, etc. Ridgeley gives it half a page and Vos addresses it even less. Vos does, however, add the following helpful notation: “This question is of the nature of a summary of the contents of questions 70-81. Therefore we shall consider it only briefly and then pass on to question 70.” (Vos, 151)

    Vos is correct as to its function in the Catechism but what the question assumes is of great significance. It focuses on the union believers have with Christ and the graces we receive from that union. Much is implied in the question and answer. Furthermore, the question will also help us to address a few matters we have briefly touched upon in our study of effectual calling. Those questions may be best addressed here.

    Communion in Grace?

    In LC #65, it says that the “members of the invisible church by Christ enjoy union and communion with him in grace and glory.” Question 69 explains what “communion in grace” means while questions 82-83 develop what “communion in glory” entails. Apart from those references, the particular language is absent in the rest of the Westminster Confession and the Catechisms. We have hinted at its meaning in our study of LC #65 but will need to develop it more here.

    Ridgeley explains it in the following manner: “Communion with Christ does not in the least import our being made partakers of any of the glories or privileges which belong to him as Mediator; but it consists in our participation of those benefits which he hath purchased for us.” Communion in grace is nothing less than participating in those benefits our Lord has purchased for us. Vos, on the other hand, does not explain this peculiar language.[1]

    The language of “communion of graces” (communication gratiarum) is found in traditional reflections on Christology (communion of properties or communicatio idiomatum) in which the human nature benefits from its union with the divine nature. The human nature “is greatly exalted in its degree of excellence by its union with deity, but not changed in kind.”[2] This may be a helpful way of better understanding the point of the LC. There is an inevitable benefit that flows to those who are united to Christ.

    In our union with Christ, we commune with Christ and all His benefits. Brakel says, “Union with Christ will necessarily result in communion with Christ.”[3] That is, if we are united to Christ in our effectual calling, we will by necessity commune with Him, “that is, the exercise and utilization of this relationship. This communion is both with the Person of Jesus Christ and with His benefits.”[4]

    James Ussher’s warm words are helpful. “What are the special comforts of this communion with Christ? That we are sure to have all graces and all good things from him, and that both our persons are beloved, and our services accepted in him and for him; John 1.16, 17. 1 Cor. 1.30. Eph. 2.4, 5.13. 1 Pet. 2.5.”[5]

    So communion in grace means that all the benefits and graces that are Christ’s are ours (“the members of the invisible church”). The answer further states that it “is their partaking of the virtue of his mediation.” That is, we partake of all that Jesus accomplished, all the benefits and power that come from HIs mediation (what He did as our Savior, as the Mediator of the New Covenant).

    The answer lists three graces in particular (justification, adoption, and sanctification) “and whatever else, in this life, manifests their union with him.” Because believers are united to Christ, these graces, benefits automatically come to us — remember, if Jesus is yours, then all that He has is yours. Christ and His benefits are the believer’s portion; “this is their portion and they have a right to it. Jesus Himself is their Jesus and all His benefits are theirs.”[6]

    The passages used (Rom. 8:30; Eph. 1:5; 1Cor. 1:30) list those graces we receive in our union with Christ. Ussher says justification and glorification are the “main benefits” of the believer’s union with Christ (using Rom. 8:30). Paul lists various graces or benefits believers receive (adoption is not listed in Rom. 8:30 and 1 Cor. 1:30 while other graces are not listed in Eph. 1:5, etc.).[7] These cluster of benefits or graces are our through our union with Christ.

    Ordo Salutis or Historia Salutis?[8]

    Reformed theologians are fond of speaking about the ordo salutis, the order of salvation (John Murray). Recently, questions have been raised as to their significance and faithfulness to Scripture. Union with Christ suggests that all these graces come to us as we commune with Him. Greater emphasis is placed on the history of salvation, the once for all salvation that has come to believers. The concern some have with the order of salvation is that we focus too much on particular steps and experiences rather than on Christ. Berkouwer, as a result, argued for the via salutis, the way of salvation. But an order of salvation is inevitable. We cannot talk about glorification without justification or adoption, calling, etc. There is a “coherence” or logical order to our salvation. We “recognize an order when we consider salvation in its internal coherence.”[9] Though we ought not to see all these graces as merely chronological, yet we should see them as logically coherent.

    Admittedly, differences have been raised as to the order within the Reformed circle but most of those differences centered on different definitions. It is proper therefore to speak of the order of salvation as long as we do not slavishly presume mere chronological order at the expense of our union with Christ. I do not believe they are mutually exclusive (the Puritans certainly did not).

    Manifesting our Union with Christ

    The catechism, after listing the three graces also notes,  “and whatever else, in this life, manifests their union with him.” That is, the innumerable benefits of our union with Christ will manifest themselves in our lives. Without going into all the particulars, we should note that whatever we need from the Lord will be ours and those graces will manifest our union with Him. Power in our weakness, joy in our suffering, new life, adoption, abiding in Him, etc. Ridgeley says, “He has received those blessings for us which he purchased by his blood; and, accordingly, is the treasury, as well as the fountain of all grace; and we are therefore said to ‘receive of his fullness, grace for grace’ [John 1:16].” (Ridgeley, 2:80)

    Lessons

    1. Therefore, we have nothing to boast about (1Cor. 1:31). Any change, any “manifestation” of our union with Christ should compel us to praise Christ. Our immediate reflex should be one of humility and not of pride. [1Cor. 15:10, But by the grace of God I am what I am, and his grace toward me was not in vain. On the contrary, I worked harder than any of them, though it was not I, but the grace of God that is with me.]

    2. We must more firmly accept the truth of Jesus’ statement, “…for apart from me you can do nothing.” (Jn. 15:5) We find that in and of ourselves, we are really nothing. It is our union with Christ and His effectual work in us through the power of the Spirit that enables us to make progress in holiness.

    3. Doesn’t our union with Christ make more sense of Paul’s longing in Phil. 3:8-11? The more we know by faith (and by experience) of the power and reality of our “connection” or union with Christ, the more we will desire Him.

    4. Is there any manifestation of union with Christ in your life? If you are truly united to Him, then you will of necessity commune with His person and graces. It is inevitable. A fruitless tree means the professing believer is not vitally united to Christ. Something must manifest itself, either our union with Christ or our union with the first Adam. Union with Christ will necessarily manifest the graces come from our communing with Him, our Redeemer and Lord.


    [1] Some theologies do not seem to spend any time developing the doctrine of union with Christ. It is not treated in Herman Hoeksema, Reformed Dogmatics (Grand Rapids: Reformed Free Publishing Association, 1966);  J. van Genderen and W. H. Velema, Concise Reformed Dogmatics, trans. Gerrit Bilkes and Ed M. van der Maas (Phillipsburg: P&R Publishing, 2008); Herman Witsius, The Economy of the Covenants Between God and Man: Comprehending a Complete Body of Divinity, trans. William Crookshank, 2 vols. (London: R. Baynes, 1822).

    [2]W. G. T. Shedd, review of The Humiliation of Christ, by A. B. Bruce, in The Presbyterian Review II (July 1881): 619. I deal with communion of properties in my notes on Christology (§ The Unipersonality of Christ).

    [3] Wilhemus á Brakel, The Christian’s Reasonable Service, ed. P, trans. Bartel Elshout, 4 vols. (Ligonier, PA: Soli Deo Gloria Publications, 1992-95), 2:90.

    [4] Brakel, The Christian’s Reasonable Service, 2:90-91.

    [5] James Ussher, A Body of Divinitie (London: Printed by William Hunt for Theodore Crowley, 1653), 191.

    [6] Brakel, The Christian’s Reasonable Service, 2:93.

    [7] Paul does not give an exhaustive list in these passages. He seems to list only those “graces” that are particularly relevant to the situation.

    [8] I develop this issue more thoroughly in my notes on Soteriology.

    [9] J. van Genderen and W. H. Velema, Concise Reformed Dogmatics, trans. Gerrit Bilkes and Ed M. van der Maas (Phillipsburg: P&R Publishing, 2008), 577.

    The Larger Catechism, #66-68

    The Larger Catechism

    Questions 66-68

    66.       Q. What is that union which the elect have with Christ?

    A. The union which the elect have with Christ is the work of God’s grace,[270] whereby they are spiritually and mystically, yet really and inseparably, joined to Christ as their head and husband;[271] which is done in their effectual calling.[272]

    67.       Q. What is effectual calling?

    A. Effectual calling is the work of God’s almighty power and grace,[273] whereby (out of his free and special love to his elect, and from nothing in them moving him thereunto)[274] he doth, in his accepted time, invite and draw them to Jesus Christ, by his Word and Spirit;[275] savingly enlightening their minds,[276] renewing and powerfully determining their wills,[277] so as they (although in themselves dead in sin) are hereby made willing and able freely to answer his call, and to accept and embrace the grace offered and conveyed therein.[278]

    68.       Q. Are the elect only effectually called?

    A. All the elect, and they only, are effectually called:[279] although others may be, and often are, outwardly called by the ministry of the Word,[280] and have some common operations of the Spirit;[281] who, for their wilful neglect and contempt of the grace offered to them, being justly left in their unbelief, do never truly come to Jesus Christ.[282]

    Scriptural Defense and Commentary

    [270] Ephesians 1:22. And hath put all things under his feet, and gave him to be the head over all things to the church. Ephesians 2:6-7. And hath raised us up together, and made us sit together in heavenly places in Christ Jesus: That in the ages to come he might show the exceeding riches of his grace in his kindness toward us through Christ Jesus. [271] 1 Corinthians 6:17. But he that is joined unto the Lord is one spirit. John 10:28. And I give unto them eternal life; and they shall never perish, neither shall any man pluck them out of my hand. Ephesians 5:23, 30. For the husband is the head of the wife, even as Christ is the head of the church: and he is the saviour of the body…. For we are members of his body, of his flesh, and of his bones. [272] 1 Peter 5:10. But the God of all grace, who hath called us unto his eternal glory by Christ Jesus, after that ye have suffered a while, make you perfect, stablish, strengthen, settle you. 1 Corinthians 1:9. God is faithful, by whom ye were called unto the fellowship of his Son Jesus Christ our Lord. [273] John 5:25. Verily, verily, I say unto you, The hour is coming, and now is, when the dead shall hear the voice of the Son of God: and they that hear shall live. Ephesians 1:18-20. The eyes of your understanding being enlightened; that ye may know what is the hope of his calling, and what the riches of the glory of his inheritance in the saints, And what is the exceeding greatness of his power to us-ward who believe, according to the working of his mighty power, Which he wrought in Christ, when he raised him from the dead, and set him at his own right hand in the heavenly places. 2 Timothy 1:8-9. Be not thou therefore ashamed of the testimony of our Lord, nor of me his prisoner: but be thou partaker of the afflictions of the gospel according to the power of God; Who hath saved us, and called us with an holy calling, not according to our works, but according to his own purpose and grace, which was given us in Christ Jesus before the world began. [274] Titus 3:4-5. But after that the kindness and love of God our Saviour toward man appeared, Not by works of righteousness which we have done, but according to his mercy he saved us, by the washing of regeneration, and renewing of the Holy Ghost. Ephesians 2:4-5, 7-9. But God, who is rich in mercy, for his great love wherewith he loved us, Even when we were dead in sins, hath quickened us together with Christ, (by grace ye are saved;)…. That in the ages to come he might show the exceeding riches of his grace in his kindness toward us through Christ Jesus. For by grace are ye saved through faith; and that not of yourselves: it is the gift of God: Not of works, lest any man should boast. Romans 9:11. For the children being not yet born, neither having done any good or evil, that the purpose of God according to election might stand, not of works, but of him that calleth. [275] 2 Corinthians 5:20. Now then we are ambassadors for Christ, as though God did beseech you by us: we pray you in Christ’s stead, be ye reconciled to God. 2 Corinthians 6:1-2. We then, as workers together with him, beseech you also that ye receive not the grace of God in vain. (For he saith, I have heard thee in a time accepted, and in the day of salvation have I succoured thee: behold, now is the accepted time; behold, now is the day of salvation.) John 6:44. No man can come to me, except the Father which hath sent me draw him: and I will raise him up at the last day. 2 Thessalonians 2:13-14. But we are bound to give thanks alway to God for you, brethren beloved of the Lord, because God hath from the beginning chosen you to salvation through sanctification of the Spirit and belief of the truth: Whereunto he called you by our gospel, to the obtaining of the glory of our Lord Jesus Christ. [276] Acts 26:18. To open their eyes, and to turn them from darkness to light, and from the power of Satan unto God, that they may receive forgiveness of sins, and inheritance among them which are sanctified by faith that is in me. 1 Corinthians 2:10, 12. But God hath revealed them unto us by his Spirit: for the Spirit searcheth all things, yea, the deep things of God…. Now we have received, not the spirit of the world, but the spirit which is of God; that we might know the things that are freely given to us of God. [277] Ezekiel 11:19. And I will give them one heart, and I will put a new spirit within you; and I will take the stony heart out of their flesh, and will give them an heart of flesh. Ezekiel 36:26-27. A new heart also will I give you, and a new spirit will I put within you: and I will take away the stony heart out of your flesh, and I will give you an heart of flesh. And I will put my spirit within you, and cause you to walk in my statutes, and ye shall keep my judgments, and do them. John 6:45. It is written in the prophets, And they shall be all taught of God. Every man therefore that hath heard, and hath learned of the Father, cometh unto me. [278] Ephesians 2:5. Even when we were dead in sins, hath quickened us together with Christ, (by grace ye are saved;) Philippians 2:13. For it is God which worketh in you both to will and to do of his good pleasure. Deuteronomy 30:6. And the LORD thy God will circumcise thine heart, and the heart of thy seed, to love the LORD thy God with all thine heart, and with all thy soul, that thou mayest live. [279] Acts 13:48. And when the Gentiles heard this, they were glad, and glorified the word of the Lord: and as many as were ordained to eternal life believed. [280] Matthew 22:14. For many are called, but few are chosen. [281] Matthew 7:22. Many will say to me in that day, Lord, Lord, have we not prophesied in thy name? and in thy name have cast out devils? and in thy name done many wonderful works? Hebrews 6:4-6. For it is impossible for those who were once enlightened, and have tasted of the heavenly gift, and were made partakers of the Holy Ghost, And have tasted the good word of God, and the powers of the world to come, If they shall fall away, to renew them again unto repentance; seeing they crucify to themselves the Son of God afresh, and put him to an open shame. [282] John 12:38-40. That the saying of Esaias the prophet might be fulfilled, which he spake, Lord, who hath believed our report? and to whom hath the arm of the Lord been revealed? Therefore they could not believe, because that Esaias said again, He hath blinded their eyes, and hardened their heart; that they should not see with their eyes, nor understand with their heart, and be converted, and I should heal them. Acts 28:25-27. And when they agreed not among themselves, they departed, after that Paul had spoken one word, Well spake the Holy Ghost by Esaias the prophet unto our fathers, Saying, Go unto this people, and say, Hearing ye shall hear, and shall not understand; and seeing ye shall see, and not perceive: For the heart of this people is waxed gross, and their ears are dull of hearing, and their eyes have they closed; lest they should see with their eyes, and hear with their ears, and understand with their heart, and should be converted, and I should heal them. John 6:64-65. But there are some of you that believe not. For Jesus knew from the beginning who they were that believed not, and who should betray him. And he said, Therefore said I unto you, that no man can come unto me, except it were given unto him of my Father. Psalm 81:11-12. But my people would not hearken to my voice; and Israel would none of me. So I gave them up unto their own hearts’ lust: and they walked in their own counsels.

    From Invisible Church to Union with Christ

    The last question dealt with the “special benefits” of the invisible church. The short answer is that the church enjoys “union and communion” with Christ. The invisible church is synonymous with the elect of God and for that reason, the ideas of union and election are combined in this question. Since union with Christ is the benefit of the invisible church, what then is that union? “What is that union which the elect have with Christ?”

    This question is more significant than it appears. If being part of the invisible church is the most important thing and the special benefits of the invisible church is union, then we definitely need to understand what that union means. This is what actually happens; this is how it happens; this is why it happens. The answers explain the actual secret workings in the elect of God.

    Most evangelical believers do not readily use “union” language though many NT scholars highlight its significance on account of their reflections on the NT. For them, it has a central place in NT theology, especially in Pauline theology.[1] How does what Christ did and what He has become mine? Union with Christ explains this concern. William Lyford says that union with Christ “is the ground of our partaking in all that Christ ever did or suffered.”[2]

    Union with Christ Defined

    Two fundamental foundations guide the definition of union with Christ. One is that it is for the elect and the second is that it is the work of God’s grace: “The union which the elect have with Christ is the work of God’s grace…” Only the elect of God are united to Christ; they alone have the benefits that come from that union. That is, not everyone is united to Christ. Some Roman Catholic theologians and liberal protestant writers teach that Christ is universally united to everyone on account of his incarnation. Only God’s elect are united to Christ (cf. Eph. 1:3-4). Furthermore, this union with Christ “is the work of God’s grace.” It is not something we do or something we affect — rather we end up “in Christ” because God accomplished it by His grace: “And because of him you are in Christ Jesus” (1Cor. 1:30, e˙x aujtouv de« uJmei√ß e˙ste e˙n Cristwˆ◊ ∆Ihsouv).[3]

    The LC defines the union in these terms: “whereby they are spiritually and mystically, yet really and inseparably, joined to Christ as their head and husband…” The two words “spiritually and mystically” mean that the union is the effect of the Spirit (and is immaterial) and is accomplished in a mysterious way. Our union is not personal (one person with Christ) or corporeal (not a bodily union). “The church is the body of Christ, and Christians are the members of Christ, but only in a spiritual sense, not in a physical or material sense of the word.” (Vos, 144) That is, we are not physical extensions of Christ (not sure if certain groups believed that we were corporeally united to Christ).[4]

    This union is real and makes us inseparable (“yet really and inseparably”). 1 Corinthians 6:17 says, “But he that is joined unto the Lord is one spirit” (oJ de« kollw¿menoß twˆ◊ kuri÷wˆ e≠n pneuvma¿ e˙stin.). A real union exists. Vos notes that we often think “spiritual” is not as real and substantial as the physical — but this union is spiritual and real. They are not mutually exclusive. Socinians apparently believed that this union was nothing more than Christ taking on our common nature.[5] It is more than that.

    The catechism states that the elect of God by the His gracious work are “joined to Christ as their head and husband…” This union simply means to be joined to Christ as our spiritual head and husband. The head image speaks of the body; the husband analogy speaks of marriage. Since Jesus is our head and husband, we are correspondingly his body and bride.

    In the body, all things are common — Christ is the head of the body. In marriage, each one benefits from the spouse and the two become one flesh so in this spiritual union, we are one with Christ. The fortunes of one affect the fortunes of the other. Paul says in Eph. 2:6, “raised us up with him and seated us with him in the heavenly places in Christ Jesus…” In our union with Christ, His session affects us and that union means that we are seated with Him in the heavenly places. How does this come about? It comes to us through God’s effectual calling.

    Effectual Calling

    Christ becomes one with us in our union with Him. In our union with Christ, we draw all our benefits from Him. This work of God’s grace in affecting the union is called “effectual calling.” It is first act on us in history and it changes everything — without this, we are lost in our sins and in darkness.

    The first thing to note is that “effectual calling is the work of God’s almighty power and grace,” — When God calls, it is powerful and effective. The word “called” is used without the word “effectual” in the Bible (e.g., Rom. 1:7; 1Cor. 1:2) but those instances reveal that the call was indeed effectual. Jesus called out Lazarus and he lived. Jesus said, “The hour is coming, and now is, when the dead shall hear the voice of the Son of God: and they that hear shall live.” (Jn. 5:25) On this verse, D. A. Carson says, “Here, …the coming hour already is: the resurrection life for the physically dead in the end time is already being manifest as life for the spiritually dead.”[6] Jesus speaks and makes those who are spiritually dead to hear and live. As he called out Lazarus from physical death, so He calls out those who are spiritually dead. It is the work of God’s almighty power and grace (cf. Eph. 1:18-20).

    This catechism further states, “whereby (out of his free and special love to his elect, and from nothing in them moving him thereunto) he doth, in his accepted time, invite and draw them to Jesus Christ, by his Word and Spirit…” God’s powerful call comes from His free and special love to the elect.  Nothing in the elect moved God to love them (it was free and voluntary). His love for them is “special” — that is, though in some qualified sense we can say God loves everyone, we must also say that God loves the elect with a special love. That love comes to historical expression by inviting and drawing sinners to Christ. That invitation comes “in his accepted time.” Though the general call of the gospel may have come to the elect numerous times, the effectual call comes “in his accepted time,” the time of God’s own choosing. It may come to him or her when an infant, a child, a teenager, a young adult, etc. “But in every case it is during the lifetime on earth of each elect person.” (Vos, 147)

    This invitation and drawing is His. That is, He is the one inviting the sinner to Jesus Christ. Paul says that the Roman Christians were “called to belong to Jesus Christ” (Rom. 1:6, uJmei√ß klhtoi« ∆Ihsouv Cristouv). Who called them? The text (vv. 1, 2) makes it clear that it was God the Father who called them.[7] It is clearer in 1Cor. 1:9, “God is faithful, by whom you were called into the fellowship of his Son, Jesus Christ our Lord (e˙klh/qhte ei˙ß koinwni÷an touv ui˚ouv aujtouv ∆Ihsouv Cristouv touv kuri÷ou hJmw◊n).”

    God the Father effectually calls the sinner into fellowship with His Son. This must be remembered. In effectual calling, the preacher or the evangelist is not one “calling” the sinner per se — effectual calling happens when God calls through the preaching of the Word. Notice the following clause — “by his Word and Spirit.” God invites by His Word and Spirit. It is not the bare Word but the Word and the Spirit. The Spirit uses the Word to draw the sinner to Himself — He ordinarily uses the Word to draw the sinner. He is not opposed to His Word (an experience contradicting His Word) — He is also not independent of His Word (a unqualified universal spiritual experience apart from God’s Word). When the Word is preached and the Spirit is not present to impress its truth, then the Word without the Spirit is ineffectual.

    As God invites by his Word and Spirit, He draws them by “savingly enlightening their minds…” The mind, we have already studied in our previous lessons, is darkened in its understanding. The preached Gospel will not be truly understood. The person may understand the individual words, the salient points of the message, etc. but cannot “savingly” understand it. All of us have heard many spiritual truths that we could repeat back to the speaker with verbal accuracy. But it does not follow that we’ve understood its significance and relevance. A cavalier response of, “Yea, yea, I know there is a fire in the house, but I don’t care.” indicates he understood the message but did not understand the true significance of it. The will also needs to change but we will deal with that point below.

    In savingly enlightening the mind, the divines assumed that the converted sinner is enabled to understand the message of the gospel. It is not merely “a religious experience.” The “lights” come on in the head, as it were. Acts 26:18 says that Paul was sent to “to open their eyes” (the eyes of unbelievers). The Lord must open our hearts to understand the message (cf. Acts 16:14, Lydia — “The Lord opened her heart to pay attention to what was said…” NASB has “to respond (prose÷cein) to the things spoken.” The Lord must open the heart to pay attention, notice, respond, etc. to the gospel. Without the work of God, our minds are hardened and a veil lies over our hearts (2Cor. 3:14). Paul says that an unbeliever is “not able to understand” the things of God (1Cor. 2:14) because we need the Spirit to understand them (cf. Mt. 16:17).

    When the Spirit works with the Word, he enables them to understand the message of the gospel. It is not a bare religious experience. A knowledge of who God is, what man and sin are, and more importantly, who Christ and His salvation are, etc. are all known in some fashion. Some knowledge must be understood and believed. In Acts 2, a preaching of Christ’s death, resurrection, and exaltation are highlighted. It brought conviction (“they were cut to the heart” 2:37) and prompted them to asked “Brothers, what shall we do?” Some gospel knowledge has to be understood and received. The Spirit enables us to understand what the Scriptures teach. He does not merely give us a spiritual experience.

    Effectual calling includes the renewal and directing of man’s will: “renewing and powerfully determining their wills, so as they (although in themselves dead in sin) are hereby made willing and able freely to answer his call, and to accept and embrace the grace offered and conveyed therein.” The promise of the New Covenant in Ezekiel was that God would put a new spirit in man (11:19) and will cause us to walk in God’s statutes (Ezek. 36:26-27); he will circumcise our hearts (Deut. 30:6). He renews our will be giving us a new spirit with a heart of flesh. He quickened us to life (Eph. 2:5) and works in us what is pleasing to Him (Phil. 2:13). God powerfully enables us so that we can freely answer His call. He makes us willing to do so. The one effectually called embraces God’s grace offered to them in the gospel. He does not leave them to merely understand the gospel by enlightening them but in fact enables them to respond — actually, enables and compels them to respond — will cause them to walk in His statutes (Ezek. 26:27).

    The person who is effectually called delights to respond to the gospel. He understands it for the first time and is desirous of it in a new manner. He truly accepts and embraces God’s offer of grace in Christ Jesus. The believer is not left to chance. God does not make alive and just sit back to see and hope that we will believe and live — He enables us both to will and to do for his good pleasure (Phi. 2:13). The person is not coerced but is truly liberated and is enabled by the Spirit to believe. He has never been freer before. Satan would have unbelievers believe that believers are in bondage and that the unbeliever’s lifestyle of sin and rebellion is freedom. The exact opposite is the truth. The sinner is truly liberated to “accept and embrace” the offer of the gospel – they are “made willing and able freely to answer his call.” No one will be with Christ who does not want to be with him (nor in heaven who does not desire to be there). God enables them to freely desire and embrace Christ offered to them.

    The Elect and Effectual Calling

    Question 68 asks who are effectually called. The answer is “all the elect, and they only, are effectually called.” The saving effects of God’s calling find their home only in God’s elect. It is effectual only in the elect because God does not apply the effects of redemption on the non-elect. Those for whom Christ died will be effectually called and in turn (and in time), receive (solely by God’s grace) the benefits of Christ’s redemption. Acts 13:48 states the following in response to Paul’s preaching, “and as many as were ordained to eternal life believed.”[8] This verse is very clear and we must correctly understand it. One commentator interprets it in the following matter: “On their part these Gentiles took an active role in believing, in committing themselves to Christ; but it was in response to God’s Spirit moving in them, convicting them, appointing them for life. All salvation is ultimately only by the grace of God.”[9] This is close to being correct but he seems to suggest that the Spirit is appointing them to eternal life by enabling them to believe. Another interpreter says, “All those who believed “were appointed for eternal life” (v. 48c).”[10] This makes the whole verse man centered. Another commentator (David Williams) also twists the whole meaning of the verse by translating it to say, “…as many as had set themselves [by their response to the Spirit’s prompting] for eternal life became believers.”[11]

    They are not faithful to the text. It says, “and as many as were appointed to eternal life believed” (kai« e˙pi÷steusan o¢soi h™san tetagme÷noi ei˙ß zwhn ai˙w¿nion). The verb “they believed” (e˙pi÷steusan) is explained by the clause “as many as were appointed to eternal life.”[12] The verse is quite clear and unambiguous. Stott notes, “Some commentators, offended by what they regard as an extreme predestinarianism in this phrase, have tried in various ways to soften it.”[13] We have given a few examples of that effort. Acts 13:48 clearly teaches that God effectually calls only those whom He has appointed to eternal life.

    Nevertheless, that does not mean that absolutely nothing happens to the non-elect when the gospel is preached. The LC explains how the Word of God affects the non-elect — “although others may be, and often are, outwardly called by the ministry of the Word…” Remember the statement of our Lord, “For many are called, but few are chosen.” (Mt. 22:14) The catechism talks about being “outwardly called by the ministry of the Word.” Through the general preaching of the Word, everyone is called to repent of his sins and believe in the Lord Jesus Christ. “This call shows men what they ought to do in order to salvation, and renders them inexcusable in case of disobedience.”[14] God sincerely does call them through the preaching of the word. Watson is again correct when he says, “God speaks not by an oracle, he calls by his ministers.” The offer of mercy and pardon, the call to repent of sin, the proclamation of the good news of our Lord Jesus Christ are presented to the unbeliever. God is using His servants to beseech all sinners to repent and believe.  This external call “is nothing else but God’s blessed tender of grace in the gospel, His parleying with sinners, when He invites them to come in and accept of mercy.”[15] But this outward call is not invested with the power to convert though it has the authority to convict and condemn as a witness on judgment day because they did not repent (cf. Rev. 9:20-21). It makes men inexcusable and their judgment inescapable.

    God the Spirit may do more with the Word than simply have it proclaimed. The catechism states that “others may… have some common operations of the Spirit.” Vos defines this phrase in this manner: “The common operations of the Spirit may convict of sin, lead to outward reformation of life of greater or lesser degree, restrain sin and evil, lead sinful people to perform acts of kindness or mercy in the human sphere, and the like. But the common operations of the Spirit fall short of salvation; they do not result in the person’s being united to Christ as his Savior in repentance and true faith.” (Vos, 149-150)[16]

    Jesus tells a parable of the sower and one of the effects is “the one who hears the word and immediately receives it with joy” (Mt. 13:20). This “rocky ground” hears and receives the preached word, even with joy! But the person eventually “falls away” (Mt. 13:21).[17] This would be an example of one who had the common operations of the Spirit which did not result in eternal life. Vos notes that the person may in fact feel smitten in their conscience and in turn may change their behavior. They may go to church, stop cursing, drinking, spending their money on sheer vanities, and actually become more tolerably pleasant. Such a person may be convinced to help out in Haiti, at the soup kitchen or simply shovel off the snow of his neighbor’s sidewalk and driveway. All these are good (in so far as being better for all of humanity) but it did not issue in regeneration and unto eternal life. Restraint from sin and reformation of life are found in those who had religious experiences as well as those who did not. Some simply come to their senses and mend their ways because they have grown tired of their old ways (e.g. give up drinking, smoking, drugs, abusing people, harmful activities, etc.).

    Hebrews 6:4-6 is perhaps the most common text to substantiate this point. Though good men may differ as how best to interpret this text, it is sufficiently clear that the listed effects of the gospel in their lives did not prevent them from falling away. These people have “tasted the good word of God” and yet are not convincingly converted. Jonathan Edwards has demonstrated that a person may experience many “religious affections” and still remain unconverted.[18] So these people are externally called and externally affected but are strangers to the real abiding effectual call of God.

    The catechism states that such people ultimately neglect the grace offered to them. The last clause states: “who, for their wilful neglect and contempt of the grace offered to them, being justly left in their unbelief, do never truly come to Jesus Christ.”  Many men and women, young men and women, and boys and girls, are content with a superficial influence of the gospel. The pleasant affects draw them. The overall terms of the gospel (called to carry the cross, die to self, submit to Christ’s Lordship, etc.) are neglected and in the end they pour contempt on the gospel. They may know much about the gospel, teach at a seminary, serve as a pastor, elder, missionary, etc. and yet they resist its full effects.

    In willfully resisting the gospel, God gives them over to their hearts. In Is. 81:11, 12 we read the following: “But my people did not listen to my voice; Israel would not submit to me. So I gave them over to their stubborn hearts, to follow their own counsels.” Israel heard the Word of God preached and declared to them but would not heed it. Calvin on this passage rightly states, “Still the external call alone would be insufficient, did not God effectually draw to himself those whom he has called.” God did not effectually draw His people when He spoke to them. We need God’s Word and God’s gracious inward call to truly benefit from His voice. Watson says, “You may resist the minister’s call, but you cannot the Spirit’s call.”[19] Without the Spirit, men will resist every appeal of every preacher.

    Judas had the gospel preached to him and did not believe (Jn. 6:64-65) and many in Israel also had the gospel preached to them (Heb. 4:2) and did not believe. The Spirit says, “Today, if you hear his voice, do not harden your hearts…” (Heb. 3:7, 8). What becomes clear is that the ability to savingly hear the gospel comes from God but our ability to refuse Him who speaks condemns us. Men refuse to heed the gospel; they willfully neglect it — the voice was heard but it was not heeded. John and Luke write about the Jews who refused to believe in Jesus and were subsequently hardened (Jn. 12:37-40; Acts 28:25-27).

    To actually come under the influence of the common operations of the Spirit should not make us content. We should earnestly listen to the Word of God so that we might be saved. We should not receive the grace of God in vain: “Behold, now is the favorable time; behold, now is the day of salvation.” (2Cor. 6:1, 2) If we simply tolerate or grow comfortable with the gospel without truly receiving, accepting, and embracing the grace offered to us, we will be judicially hardened. Whatever we might think of the “lawless one” in 2Thess. 2:9ff., one thing becomes clear, our self-deception will be our own undoing. “Therefore God sends them a strong delusion, so that they may believe what is false, in order that all may be condemned who did not believe the truth but had pleasure in unrighteousness.” (2Thess. 2:11-12)

    People who have heard the gospel for years, covenant children who have heard the gospel all their lives, elderly church people who have always attended church, etc. must not confuse being exposed to the gospel with embracing it.  The common operations of the Spirit they received cannot get them to heaven. They have been externally called all their lives but have they been effectually called?

     


    [1] Cf. James D. G. Dunn, The Theology of Paul the Apostle (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1998), 390ff.; Udo Schnelle, Apostle Paul: His Life and Theology, trans. M. Eugene Boring (Grand Rapids: Baker Academic, 2005), 479-482; Leonhard Goppelt, Theology of the New Testament, trans. John E. Alsup, 2 vols. (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1982), 2:105-6.

    [2] William Lyford, The Instructed Christian (1655; Ligonier, PA: Soli Deo Gloria, nd), 138.

    [3] NIV has, “It is because of him that you are in Christ Jesus…”; NASB has “But by His doing you are in Christ Jesus…”

    [4] Lyford , The Instructed Christian, 130-1 seems to suggest that it was. He cites Robert Watsfield and Henry Nichols seemed to have believed in some sort of carnal union and indwelling (and also of deifying man through the union), see pp. 125-6.

    [5] Thomas Ridgeley, Commentary on the Larger Catechism, 2 vols. (1855; reprint, Edmonton, AB Canada: Still Waters Revival Books, 1993), 2:45.

    [6] D. A. Carson, The Gospel According to John (PNTC; Accordance electronic ed. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1991), 256.

    [7] John Murray, Epistle to the Romans, The New International Commentary on the New Testament (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1959-1965), 1:14, 15: “It is not probable that “called of Jesus Christ” indicates that Jesus Christ is conceived of as the author of the call. For uniformly God the Father is represented as the author (cf. 8:30; 11:29; 1 Cor. 1:9; 2 Tim. 1:9). They are the called of Jesus Christ in the sense of belonging to Christ inasmuch as they are called by the Father into the fellowship of his Son (1 Cor. 1:9).”

    [8] The whole verse reads, “And when the Gentiles heard this, they began rejoicing and glorifying the word of the Lord, and as many as were appointed to eternal life believed.”

    [9] John B. Polhill, Acts (NAC 26; ed. E. Ray Clendenen; Accordance electronic ed. Nashville: Broadman & Holman Publishers, 1992), 308.

    [10] Ajith Fernando, Acts (NIVAC; ed. Terry C. Muck; Accordance electronic ed. Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1998), 388.

    [11] David J. Williams, Acts, New International Biblical Commentary (Peabody, MA: Hendrickson, 1990), 239.

    [12] The subject of the third person plural is the nominative plural: “They, that is, as many as were appointed to eternal life, believed.”

    [13] John R.W. Stott, The Message of Acts (The Bible Speaks Today; Accordance electronic ed. Downers Grove.: InterVarsity Press, 1994), 227.

    [14] Thomas Watson, A Body of Divinity (Grand Rapids: Sovereign Grace Publishers, nd), 153.

    [15] Thomas Watson, All Things for Good, Puritan Paperbacks (Carlise: Banner of Truth, 1986), 104.

    [16] Ridgeley says something similar: “Their consciences are sometimes awakened, and they bring many charges and accusations against themselves; and from a dread of consequences, they abstain from many enormous crimes, as well as practice several duties of religion. They are also said to be made partakers of some great degrees of restraining grace.” (2:49)

    [17] The proof text includes Mt. 7:22, “Many will say to me in that day, Lord, Lord, have we not prophesied in thy name? and in thy name have cast out devils? and in thy name done many wonderful works?”

    [18] Cf. Jonathan Edwards, Religious Affections, Works of Jonathan Edwards, vol. 2 (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1959).

    [19] Watson, All Things for Good, 108.